A Pragmatic Theory of Fallacy (Studies in Rhetoric and by Douglas Walton

By Douglas Walton

Even though fallacies were universal considering the fact that Aristotle,
until eventually lately little cognizance has been dedicated to picking out and defining
them. in addition, the concept that of fallacy itself has lacked a sufficiently
transparent intending to make it a useful gizmo for comparing arguments. Douglas
Walton takes a brand new analytical examine the concept that of fallacy and presents
an up to date research of its usefulness for argumentation reviews. Walton
makes use of case experiences illustrating frequent arguments and difficult deceptions
in daily dialog the place the cost of fallaciousness is at issue.
the varied case reviews exhibit in concrete phrases many sensible aspects
of ways to take advantage of textual proof to spot and study fallacies and to
overview arguments as mistaken. Walton appears at how a controversy is used
within the context of dialog. He defines a fallacy as a conversational
stream, or series of strikes, that's presupposed to be a controversy that contributes
to the aim of the dialog yet in truth interferes with it. The
view is a practical one, in response to the belief that after humans argue,
they accomplish that in a context of debate, a conventionalized normative framework
that's goal-directed. one of these contextual framework is proven to be crucial
in identifying even if a controversy has been used competently. Walton also
indicates how examples of fallacies given within the common sense textbooks characteristically
become editions of moderate, whether defeasible or questionable
arguments, according to presumptive reasoning. this is often the essence of the evaluation
challenge. A key thesis of the publication, which must never be taken for granted
as past textbooks have so usually performed, is for you to spot a fallacy
from the way it was once utilized in a context of debate. this can be an leading edge and
even, as Walton notes, "a radical and controversial" theory
of fallacy.

Show description

Read Online or Download A Pragmatic Theory of Fallacy (Studies in Rhetoric and Communication) PDF

Similar rhetoric books

Presidential Speechwriting: From the New Deal to the Reagan Revolution and Beyond (Presidential Rhetoric Series, 7)

The increase of the media presidency via radio and tv declares has heightened the significance of presidential speeches in identifying the U. S. president's effectiveness and recognition. no longer strangely, this improvement has additionally witnessed the increase speechwriters. The chapters during this booklet (two through former White residence speechwriters) provide perception into the method of presidential speechwriting, from Franklin D.

Twentieth-Century American Success Rhetoric: How to Construct a Suitable Self

Self-help authors like Tom Peters and Stephen Covey, who've ruled best-seller lists over the past twenty years, have exercised expanding impact on political, governmental, and academic firms. in contrast, the subject of yankee luck books— texts that promise to assist readers be successful by way of retrofitting their id to fulfill office demands—has been missed by means of students because the Eighties.

The art of dialectic between dialogue and rhetoric : the Aristotelian tradition

This e-book reconstructs the culture of dialectic from Aristotle's subject matters, its founding textual content, as much as its "renaissance" in sixteenth century Italy, and specializes in the position of dialectic within the construction of data. Aristotle defines dialectic as a based trade of questions and solutions and hence hyperlinks it to discussion and disputation, whereas Cicero develops a mildly skeptical model of dialectic, identifies it with reasoning in utramque partem and connects it heavily to rhetoric.

Imagining the Cosmopolitan in Public and Professional Writing

During this vital booklet, Surma combines threads from moral, political, communications, sociological, feminist and discourse theories to discover the effect of writing in a number contexts and illustrate the ways that it may well advance social connections.

Additional resources for A Pragmatic Theory of Fallacy (Studies in Rhetoric and Communication)

Sample text

E. pa and pagmata (p. 29. 7–11 Rabe); the division in Hermogenes and his commentators is discussed by Schouler (1990). n, relies on the two categories in its introductory lines (p. 93. 5–8). 28 Introduction he interpreted the loci. We can also draw on the middle part of the book where Cicero gives advice as to how to use the various loci. I give a summary of what will be discussed in detail in the commentary. Finding an argument with the help of the loci is to work in such a way that, if, for instance, ‘The ius civile is something useful’ is the proposition to be proved, one will consider the definition of ius civile to see whether it can provide an argument.

That the Stoics took Strato to be the last Peripatetic who was interested in dialectic seems to emerge from Plut. De Sto. Rep. 24. 1045 f (fr. 19 W. ¼ SVF ii. 126). 21 It is now the communis opinio that both works depend for the treatment of inventio on one common source; conclusive arguments for this position have been provided by Adamietz (1960). Still under discussion is whether this source was a book or a lecture course from which both authors took notes, possibly at different times; cf.

In Cicero’s rhetorical contexts Aristotle seems to be a name for a tradition that stretches down to the Academic Philo. If Philo actually used the t opoi, he would of course have had a concrete reason for acknowledging an indebtedness to Aristotle. And it is conceivable that Cicero in turn would have preferred to link his campaign for thetical rhetoric not so much with Philo but with the great name of Aristotle. It is also remarkable that in Cicero general information about philosophers who give instruction on the kind of rhetoric in question here usually includes a reference to both the Peripatetics and the Academics (Fin.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.95 of 5 – based on 13 votes